3Autos.com » gas mileage,mileage,car guy » Autoblog Reader Rant: lower octane gas – a good idea?

Autoblog Reader Rant: lower octane gas – a good idea?

1 October 2005 Filed under: Trends View: 11 Digg Yahoo! Buzz StumbleUpon Technorati del.icio.us Mixx Facebook TwitThis Reddit YahooMyWeb Google feedburner
Autoblog Reader Rant: lower octane gas – a good idea?

Ron is from Alaska and he wrote us it seems just to vent some frustration about the lack of high octane gasoline in his native state. His rant enlightened us on what it's like to be a car guy suffering from too much northern exposure, so we thought we'd share his diatribe with the whole class.     

>> I live in Alaska. As of August 2004, the highest octane gasoline available has been 90. Not 91, as is available in CA, but 90! As some of your readers may note, running newer vehicles on 90-octane gas can cause numerous problems, the least of which is degraded performance and mileage. The reason, as I understand it, for our reduced octane juice is environmental and/or financial as in more costly to distribute as it's not produced locally for cars.  

The possibility that this could be better for the environment is absolutely preposterous…

Imagine this scenario: I fill up with the new, lower octane gas. My car pings and bogs when accelerating which causes me to use the go-pedal more which in turn uses more gas. The result is lower MPG, higher gas bills, and less driving enjoyment. To resolve part of the situation, I start adding octane boost to every tank of gas. Octane boost costs between $2 and $12 depending on the gas station or automotive store being frequented. After adding octane boost, I toss the empty container in the trash. Where does the empty container go? Back into the ground. Is it really empty? Probably not as there is still residue and some small amount of octane boost left in it.

What does that do to the environment? Who knows, but you get the idea.

So, where does that leave us:
Higher octane gas - no user contributed additives, decent performance, OK gas mileage
Lower octane gas - User contributed additives, more toxic trash, worse performance, more gasoline required due to worse MPG

Is anyone listening or am I just another disembodied voice?

Digg Technorati StumbleUpon Mixx del.icio.us Reddit BlinkList Furl YahooMyWeb feedburner
  • Forbes apologizes for not liking American cars even more I love stories about lists: 10 best, best quality, gas mileage, etc. But here's one that baffles me. I don't understand why Forbes, an insightful reputable publication, would write a story about 10 go ...
  • Honda thinking U.S. diesel Even though Honda is one of the leading hybrid brands in the U.S. they're also looking into the possibility of bringing diesel engines to North America. But the problem of stringent U.S. emission stan ...
  • Green incognito The different voices from AutoWeek's editorial review crew usually span the gamut of opinions for the car they are reviewing. The Honda Accord hybrid has evoked almost all positive responses, many of ...
  • Lexus RX 400h gets thumbs up Ann M. Job hands in a terrific review of the first luxury hybrid SUV. The sticker shock of $49,185 might be too much for the average environmentalist to handle, but from this review it sounds like SUV ...
  • GM's full size vans get Duramax power GM has finally shoehorned the Duramax 6600 in the 2006 Chevrolet Express and GMC Savana heavy-duty van offerings. It not only improves power (250 hp/460 lb.-ft) but is estimated to improve gas mileage ...
  • 2005 Avalon, a better Lexus? The testers over at The Car Connection seem to think so. The car is bigger, more powerful, gets better gas mileage and is cheaper (except for the Limited) than the ES 330. While I can't argue with any ...
  • Is the grass greener on the Accord Hybrid side? The Detroit News completed a quick road test of the new Honda Accord Hybrid and was a little disappointed. First, the review feeds into my view of hybrids right now: People buy the Prius in droves bec ...
  • Freestyle "greater than" Pacifica? Edmunds.com completed a road test of the new Ford Freestyle and gives it the thumbs up against its main competitor, the Chrysler Pacifica. One gripe was with the engine, what else. When the SUV was lo ...
  • Consumer Reports reliability survey, sheah, right In my favorite survey, right next to the JD Power Initial Quality survey, Consumer Reports lists their "most reliable" cars. Well, their press release really doesn't tell the reader what their interpr ...
  • Cupholders over mileage A new survey found more car buyers were concerned with the cupholders in a new vehicle than with the gas mileage. That's right, 56% of car-buyers care about their cupholders while only 40% are interes ...

0 Responses to » Autoblog Reader Rant: lower octane gas – a good idea?

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.