3Autos.com » automakers,fuel economy,suvs » Should hybrids be green, mean, or both?

Should hybrids be green, mean, or both?

27 November 2005 Filed under: Trends View: 7 Digg Yahoo! Buzz StumbleUpon Technorati del.icio.us Mixx Facebook TwitThis Reddit YahooMyWeb Google feedburner
Should hybrids be green, mean, or both?

A tip from Autoblog reader Glenn L. points us to this well-balanced Canadian article about the trend for manufacturers to offer big, powerful hybrids, instead of the small, ultra-fuel efficient cars that sparked the buzz about hybrids in the first place. Typical of the trend are GM's hybrid pickups and SUVs, and the Lexus 400h performance SUV.

The trend has disturbed many environmentally-concerned car buyers, who would rather see automakers focus on maximum fuel economy/minimum emissions small sedans. But pragmatic manufacturers are looking at the harsh realities of the marketplace - they have a considerable investment in trucks and large SUVs, an investment that reflected a real market demand.

As a GM engineer points out, increasing an SUV's fuel consumption from 10 mpg to 11 mpg saves 110 gallons of gas every 12,000 miles. In contrast, increasing a small sedan's fuel economy from 30 mpg to 40 mpg over the same distance only saves 100 gallons. (Obviously, replacing the SUV with the sedan would be the ideal solution from a purely environmental standpoint, but that would apply - albeit less dramatically - even if the sedan were not a hybrid.)

Of course, large vehicles are also the easiest to convert to hybrid powertrains, with plenty of room and load capacity for the added hybrid components. Some will argue that when your only tool is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail, and there's some truth to that, too.

So for now, perhaps fans of the hybrid solution will have to be content with small victories, as the big manufacturers ponderously change course toward a more fuel efficient future.

As an aside - this subject has been the subject of spirited debate right here in Autoblog's comment sections, showing once again that our readers are ahead of the curve! We're not looking to (re-) ignite a flame war with this post - just alerting everyone to a useful summary article.

[Thanks, Glenn!]

Digg Technorati StumbleUpon Mixx del.icio.us Reddit BlinkList Furl YahooMyWeb feedburner
  • AWD Magnum test Now that the all-wheel drive Magnums and 300s are hitting the streets and winter weather is coming, I thought it would be prudent to give a link to the first AWD test I've seen. The DCX system gives a ...
  • More hybrids = less batteries USA Today is reporting that automakers like Ford might find it hard in the next few years to find the expensive battery packs required to fuel hybrid cars like the new Escape. The expensive power pack ...
  • Autoguy discusses Peak Oil and how it could impact our precious babies And by precious babies I mean our cars. We try and stay away from being political at Autoblog but there's no arguing that fossil fuels of any kind run out and some say oil could start a decline soon, ...
  • Lavish new ways to sell cars Ed Garsten over at the Detroit News takes a deeper look into the trend of alternative sales pitches by manufacturers. A few weeks back we posted a story about the Black Eyed Peas playing a concert to ...
  • Is the USA ready for China's invasion? Since yesterday was when automakers reported October monthly sales, all that's in the news today is how the Asian manufacturers gained share and the Domestics lost share. It's inevitable. When there a ...
  • GM plus SEMA equals specialty concepts GM is stocking their booths full of specialty concepts for this years SEMA show in Las Vegas. Some of the show stoppers in 2004 include the Cobalt 272 shown in the picture, Colorado SS complete w ...
  • GM, Ford cut inventory, hopefully incentives The US consumer seems immune to the current pile of incentives that automakers have doled out on their last of the 04's, and dealers are pushing back from the money-losing race. GM anno ...
  • Anaheim show gets some exposure Every year I'm amazed at how many of the country's auto shows are getting to debut new models. Before only Detroit premiered the biggest and baddest. Then it Chicago started to debut more and more car ...
  • Hands free not safer Cell phone addicts, automakers and lawmakers are scratching their heads. For the past few years they've all been advocating the use of hands free cell phones to stem the tide of 2,600 annual deaths li ...
  • St. Louis man builds engine that runs on vapor After reading this story my mind was blown. I'm not a mechanic, but Bill Cain is. He's been rebuilding cars since he was a teenager. Recently he built an engine for a 1970 Plymouth Fury that recycled ...

0 Responses to » Should hybrids be green, mean, or both?

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.